The Use of Reverse Vesting Orders to Maximize Recovery in Commercial Mortgage Enforcement
Key considerations for lawyers acting for secured lenders
Commercial mortgage enforcement is often advanced by way of foreclosure proceedings, which can involve a court-appointed receiver. While secured lenders may be focused on a speedy and simple realization process, to maximize recovery some commercial mortgage enforcement matters favour an approach that borrows a concept developed in commercial restructuring proceedings: the reverse vesting order (“RVO”).
What is a Reverse Vesting Order?
A court-ordered sale is often subject to an approval and vesting order (“AVO”). Under an AVO, the court vests purchased assets in the purchaser free and clear of claims, liens and encumbrances, while unwanted liabilities remain in the debtor’s estate. Conversely, with an RVO, the debtor company transfers any unwanted liabilities or assets into a residual company and the purchaser acquires all of the shares of the debtor company. For the purchaser, the debtor company remains intact, free of any unwanted liabilities, and still holding any valuable assets, such as permits, licenses, contracts, or tax attributes, that may not be transferable to a purchaser by AVO.
An RVO approves a transaction that is akin to a share sale, rather than an asset sale. By selling the shares of the debtor company, an RVO maintains valuable, potentially non-transferrable, assets with the debtor company. Unlike a traditional share sale, an RVO goes further and excludes unwanted liabilities, assets or residual claims, which are transferred from the debtor company to, or vested in, a residual or “junk” company.
RVOs have been approved under both the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, RSC 1985, c B-3, including receivership proceedings under s. 243 (see British Columbia v Peakhill Capital Inc., 2024 BCCA 246 [Peakhill]), and the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act, RSC 1985, c C-36. Before approving an RVO, the court will consider whether the RVO is necessary, whether it will produce an economic result that is at least as favorable as any other viable alternative, if any stakeholder is worse off than they would be under a different viable alternative, and whether consideration reflects the importance and value of the licences and permits (or other intangible assets) being preserved under the RVO structure (Harte Gold Corp. (Re), 2022 ONSC 653 at para 28). If the proposed structure improperly strips creditors of rights, or avoids protections they otherwise may have, it may not be approved.
How RVOs can Increase Value in Commercial Mortgage Enforcement
By selling shares of the debtor company, an RVO can be used to realize the value of non-transferable assets or avoid transfer costs. This may include maintaining licenses, permits, contracts or tax attributes, or avoiding transfer taxes. Since an RVO increases value for prospective purchasers, such transactions can increase realizable value for secured lenders.
RVOs can increase recoveries (i) when the debtor company’s assets depend on continuity, regulatory approvals, permits and licenses (see Delta 9 Cannabis Inc (Re), 2025 ABKB 52, and 9408-7129 Québec inc., 2025 QCCS 2180); and (ii) by preserving non-transferable rights, such as tax attributes (see Tacora Resources Inc. (Re), 2024 ONSC 4436 [Tacora], and PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. v Canada Fluorspar (NL) Inc., 2023 NLSC 88 [Fluorspar]).
An RVO can be particularly valuable in many commercial mortgage enforcement matters to avoid the payment of transfer tax. Depending on the province, the sale of shares rather than the underlying property may avoid transfer tax, potentially increasing lender recoveries (see Peakhill and Séquestre de 9408-7129 Québec inc., 2025 QCCS 2180 [9408-7129]). In Peakhill, by avoiding the transfer of the real property, the RVO transaction did not attract property transfer tax under the British Columbia Property Transfer Tax Act, RSBC 1996, c 378, which increased creditor recovery by approximately $3.5 million.
The Future Role of RVOs in Commercial Mortgage Enforcement
RVOs are becoming increasingly relevant in Canadian commercial mortgage enforcement practice as the current market increases attention on maximizing total value. An RVO can be a powerful tool, but should be well supported by evidence, a proper sale process, transparency, and careful attention to any creditor rights that are affected by the structure.
When acting for secured lenders on commercial mortgage enforcement, lawyers should consider whether the assets include non-transferable assets that may be better realized through an RVO, or whether tax considerations could improve the purchase price or recovery if the deal is structured as an RVO.